They Say/ I Say Review
Reading and Responding to Texts
In a thesis driven, argumentative essay, defend a clear position using two selected essays
From Chapter 14 of They Say/ I Say.
Directions:
Skim the Table of Contents that lists the titles of included publications. Read the publications that spark your interest and select two of these publications that you feel you will be able to analyze. Read each publication carefully, taking note of which argument you feel is more successful.
Goal:
Present an analysis on the structure of the author’s argument in each article, proving why one argument is stronger than the other. Do not challenge the topic the author has discussed. Consider aspects such as the evidence, argument, and tone used by the authors. As this is an argumentative essay, the goal of your writing should be to persuade your audience to agree with your position.
Purpose:
The purpose of this essay is to make a claim and support it with evidence from the essays and outside research. You are attempting to prove something while at the same time attempting to persuade your reader to hold your position. Remember that claims without support are just opinion, so extensive support will be necessary.
Requirements
- 4 Double Spaced Pages
- MLA Style with Proper Heading
- 3 Academic Sources (Parenthetical References Required)
- Times New Roman Font
- 12pt Font Size
- 1” Margins
Due Dates:
The essay will be due in portions as a first draft, second draft, and final draft. It is important that you complete your work on time so that you can participate in our Peer Review sessions. Please make arrangements to go to the Writing Lab at the LRC if you need any assistance with this essay, and as always, you can come see me with any questions or anxiety you may be experiencing.
Answer Preview-They Say/ I Say Review
